Opinion

Fail - to succeed!

Posted by David Bamford

02-Jan-2017

petromall.org


Exploration is in fact a scientific enterprise – as well as a business: we make predictions and then test them with the drill bit. And we aim to learn from these tests. And try again.

On a recent vacation one of my Kindle reading items was Matthew Syed's book “Black Box Thinking”.

In it he uses a variety of examples to illustrate how learning from failure is critical to ultimate success, drawing on examples ranging from a boy called David Beckham learning firstly how to get to over 2000 “keepy-uppies” and then to take bendy free kicks to James Dyson trying over 5000 versions of his revolutionary cyclone cleaner before he got to one that worked perfectly.

This set me thinking about whether we Explorers have a system within which we can truly learn from failures (also known as drilling dry holes)?

In principle I believe we do. We assess risks pre-drill against a range of possible key factors (source presence, migration, reservoir presence, trap etc) and post-drill at least engage in a narrative as to why the well failed if it did.



Perhaps we are not as ruthless pre-drill as we might be, asking “if we drill and this turns out to be a dry hole, what will be the reason?”….what one of my ex-BP colleagues called ‘the dangling loose thread' which if you pull on it will make the whole thing fall apart.

But where we are not so good is learning from failures, I assert, especially because we do not share insights between companies either easily or willingly.

To this extent, the UK's OGA is to be given an A for effort in compiling a review of wells drilled in the Central North Sea/Moray Firth area, this involving persuading a good number of companies to show their dirty linen in public.

Unfortunately, I have to give them D for the outcome as the result is almost entirely narrative with no attempt at science. Why do I say that? Because it left me with absolutely no idea what I would do differently to succeed in that particular oil & gas region. Or whether the region was itself a waste of time...


Visit source site

petromall.org

UKNorth Sea

More items from david


New life for the North Sea!

Conventional petroleum provinces in the North Sea range from mature to very mature, and thus it seems that future will be defined in terms of  “marginal discoveries” - the OGA estimates that there are already  ~350 unsanctioned discoveries in the UKCS – and possibly shale oil/gas, with the intriguin ...

David Bamford


Posted 18 days agoOpinion > North SeaMarginal DiscoveriesUK Shale +1

The case for East Africa

East Africa still seems relatively unloved as a petroleum province and yet it has a number of positive aspects: There is a regional entity, the East African Community , which draws together Kenya, Uganda, and Tanzania (but not Mocambique). There is a declared ambition to bring energy to the comb ...

David Bamford


Posted 18 days agoOpinion > East AfricaDIT

Joined-up thinking about the North Sea?

There seems to be a lot of thought going into the issue of Decommissioning in the North Sea, with companies perhaps beginning to realise that the traditional approach – to take a ‘finger in the air' estimate of the potential costs to put into their accounts and then breathe a sigh of relief when the ...

David Bamford


Posted 1 month agoOpinion > North SeaDecommissioningMarginal Discoveries +2

In praise of seeps?

I knew from early in my time at BP that the previous generation of explorers had used surface seeps to locate oil reservoirs in the Middle East – find a surface seep in the middle of a map-able anticline…….. Then when I was involved in BP's Gulf of Mexico exploration, I understood that you could se ...

David Bamford


Posted 1 month agoOpinion > SeepsGeophysicsSatellite Data +2

Give us a Carbon Tax!

It seems like the Majors (and some of their NOC friends) are aligned in appealing for a Carbon Tax, specifically a tax on carbon emissions from oil & gas operations. The cynics amongst you might question the motives of the folk appealing for this – does it ‘knife' a significant number of competitor ...

David Bamford


Posted 1 month agoOpinion > Carbon TaxShellPremier Oil +1
All posts from david